Choosing the right instructional design (ID) program can be overwhelming, there are more options than ever, and not all of them will help you get where you want to go. In this post I will go through criteria that should help you evaluate a program before applying:
1. Start With Your Career Goals
Before diving into school websites, ask yourself: What do I want to do with this degree?
Instructional design programs are not one-size-fits-all. Some are geared toward:
- Corporate/Workplace Learning
- K-12 or Higher Education Instruction
- Academic or Learning Sciences Research
You want a program that aligns with your desired career path. If you’re looking to work in corporate training, a program that’s heavily focused on K-12 pedagogy may not be the best fit (and vice versa).
2. Understand the Degree Type
Not all master’s degrees in instructional design are created equal. Here’s a general guide:
- MA (Master of Arts): Typically K-12 or research-heavy
- MEd (Master of Education): Often geared toward educator practitioner roles
- MS (Master of Science): Often geared toward corporate/practitioner roles
This isn’t a hard rule, but it’s a good starting point when evaluating programs. Always check course descriptions and talk to faculty and students
3. Research the Faculty
Look up the faculty. Seriously.
Do they have experience in the areas you care about? For example, if you’re interested in becoming a corporate instructional designer, is there a faculty member who’s worked in that world?
You should be able to see faculty bios, resumes, LinkedIn profiles, and research or industry experience on the program’s website. If you can’t find this info, that’s a red flag.
And don’t stop there, talk to them. Ask about their approach, their industry connections, and how they mentor students.
4. Ask About Mentorship and Career Support
Great programs don’t just teach, they guide.
- Will a faculty member help with your resume or portfolio?
- Do they help students land internships or full-time roles?
- Are you getting 1:1 mentorship, or are you just a number?
Strong mentorship can be the difference between landing a job in 6 weeks vs. 6 months post-graduation.
5. Does the Program Website Actually Tell You Anything?
If the program’s website is vague or doesn’t list course details, required skills, or faculty info, walk away.
You’re not just choosing a school, you’re investing time and money into your career. Transparency matters.
6. Look for an Active Alumni Network
This is one of the most underrated aspects of choosing a program.
Ask:
- Is there a LinkedIn group or alumni Slack/Discord?
- Do alumni help each other with jobs, internships, and referrals?
For example, in the program I teach at in North Carolina, we have alumni working all across the state, and they regularly help current students break into the field. That kind of local network is priceless especially when that’s where you want to live/work.
7. Where (company and location) Are Students Working After Graduation?
If you’re looking to get into corporate L&D, but graduates are mostly going into school systems or academia, that’s a mismatch.
Ask for examples of recent graduates and where they’ve been hired. Make sure that list reflects your goals and your geographic preferences. If the school is in California and the students are all working in California but you want to live/work in NY, then that might not be the best fit for you.
8. Work Experience & Portfolio
This is big: Will you build a portfolio in the program and get real work experience?
- Are there internship opportunities?
- Will you work with real clients on a capstone or project?
- Will you get experience designing e-learning, video content, or simulations?
Employers want to see what you can do and get someone with actual work experience in the field before they take a chance on you. You must have some type of internship to get your resume past the initial screening. Portfolio comes into play when they have gotten down to the final few candidates and will want to review your work.
9. Cost
Instructional design programs should be affordable. In-state public universities in your state are often your best bet.
For example, the program I teach in costs roughly:
- $10–12K total for a full Master’s degree
- $5–6K for a graduate certificate
If a school is charging $25–50K for an ID degree, ask why. You should not be taking on massive debt for this field.
10. Time to Completion
A standard instructional design master’s should take 1–2 years max. If the average is pushing 3 years or more, that’s edging into Ph.D. territory, and could signal poor advising or overloaded schedules.
11. Curriculum: Theory, Design, & Development/Tech
A balanced ID program should cover:
- Learning theory
- Instructional design models
- Front-end analysis
- Project management
- Evaluation
- Learning technologies/Development Software
- Data & AI tools in education
You want both big-picture thinking and hands-on skills. Programs that overemphasize theory without development practice (or vice versa) can leave you unprepared.
12. Software and Tools Access
By 2025, you should be getting exposure to the tools employers expect. At a minimum, the program should include:
- Articulate Storyline & Rise
- Adobe Captivate
- Figma
- Photoshop
- Adobe Premiere or Camtasia
- LMS platforms (Canvas, Moodle, Blackboard, etc.)
- Some entry-level coding (HTML, CSS, JavaScript)
And you shouldn’t have to buy all this software yourself. Programs should provide free access while you’re enrolled. For example, students in our program get full access to Adobe Creative Cloud and Articulate tools at no extra cost.
Final Thoughts
These criteria haven’t changed much in the last few years, but with more programs moving online and new tech like AI and data analytics becoming part of the field, it’s even more important to be selective. Don’t just pick a school, pick the right school for you. The program that’s best for one student might not be the best for you for the reasons outlined in this post